Skip to main content
film review

The Secret Trial 5 is a film about the human impact of the "War on Terror."<137>Noah G. Bingham<137><137><252><137>

It seems inconceivable – a Kafkaesque nightmare come to life.

Here in utopian, civil rights-upholding Canada, five men have spent a total of over 50 years in prison or under house arrest, even though none has ever been charged with a crime. The men – Muslims all, natch – were each arrested between 1999 and 2003 under a so-called security certificate, a blunt instrument of immigration law that enables the federal government to detain non-citizens it suspects of being potential dangers to national security. But because the evidence is kept secret, to protect sources, detainees can never clear their names.

First-time director Amar Wala gave himself a corker of an assignment with this case, a messy stew of constitutional law and the personal dramas of four men and their families, which unfold over more than a dozen years. So if the filmmaking is bumpy – tonal shifts, jarring cuts between interviews conducted years apart, and herky-jerky individual narratives that reach different conclusions – its quiet moral outrage never wavers.

Wala gives the final word to the son of one of the men, who was a mere child when his father was first arrested. "Our strength is in our humanity, our justice system, and who we are as a people," he says, displaying impressive, improbable hope. "If you let fear dictate how you live your life, then you lose everything."

Follow related authors and topics

Authors and topics you follow will be added to your personal news feed in Following.

Interact with The Globe