Skip to main content

The Globe and Mail

Cadillac SUV bests German rivals by a landslide

Overall Rating
8.5
Overall
As a premium crossover all on its own, the SRX looks and plays the part, but the biggest selling feature of all is the value story – you get a lot for the money. You will like this vehicle if: you’re chasing a crossover with aggressive looks, sporty performance and more gear than you get in rivals priced much higher.
Looks Rating
8.5
Looks
The hard edges and sharp lines take the SRX to the edge but without going over. In a class filled with some fairly bland designs, the SRX stands out.
Interior Rating
7.5
Interior
The cabin layout is smart and appealing. The instruments have soft blue-ish lighting and the centre stack is easy to decipher and use.
Ride Rating
8.5
Ride
Quite firm. The fully independent suspension is tuned on the sporty side, while the power steering – hydraulic – has just the right amount of boost is you like to drive.
Safety Rating
9
Safety
Airbags and driving nannies all over the place and an IIHS Top Safety Pick.
Green Rating
6
Green
The V-6 is strong and thirsty, but at least it needs just regular fuel to perform as advertised.

Okay, a couple of quick questions:

First, which of these crossovers did not rank among the top three in their class in the latest J.D. Power and Associates Initial Quality Study: Cadillac SRX, Infiniti FX, Lexus RX, Mercedes-Benz ML?

Second, which of these brands ranked highest in the overall IQS: Cadillac, Infiniti, Mercedes-Benz, BMW?

Story continues below advertisement

The answer to the first question is the ML, the second Cadillac. So how many of you budding luxury crossover buyers have the SRX on your radar screen? Been for a test drive? Priced out head-to-head an SRX versus, say, a comparable FX, RX and ML? How many? Really and truly, how many?

True enough, we can quibble and argue about the strength of the respective brands, that if you want a Caddy in Canada you must buy it in a showroom also loaded with Chevy Sparks and GMC Sierra pickups. You can point out that the premium ownership experience is better at the others because every Lexus, Infiniti and Merc is sold at a standalone dealership, while GM's four brands for the most part are lumped together under a single dealership roof.

I agree that the lack of a separate Cadillac dealership network in Canada is a big problem for General Motors' premium, top-of-the-line brand. I don't agree, however, that when it comes to the SRX, Cadillac takes a back seat to the likes of the FX, ML and RX, to name three.

And when it comes to pricing head-to-head, the Caddy wins. I know this because I've done it here with the help of my Autodata comparison software. I can tell you that the exercise is quite a revelation. Shocking really. And Caddy wins by a landslide. Why? So much is standard in a $54,740 SRX Premium model with all-wheel-drive.

This means that if you want to bring an FX35 Premium up to an equal equipment level, add more than $8,000 to the $53,350 base price. The RX350, with its hugely appealing $44,950 base, needs some $14,500 in extras. Do that and you not only wipe out the basic sticker price advantage, you are left with an options-in RX at $61,445. That gives the SRX an overall all-in edge of more than $5,000.

The ML350 from Mercedes? To make it an equipment match to the SRX Premium, you must start ticking the options boxes at the Merc dealer. When you're done ordering $13,900 in options, the $57,900 ML350 becomes a $72,500 ML350. Advantage SRX. By – sit down -- $16,165.

Of course, until this year, until Caddy fixed the SRX's engine problem, I would not have felt it fair to make a head-to-head comparison such as this. But the SRX's new 3.6-litre direct-injected V-6 (308 hp and 265 lb-ft of torque) makes a world of difference. Last year's base V-6, an over-matched 3.0-litre V-6, lacked needed torque and refinement and the 2.8-litre turbocharged upgrade, while more powerful, was a jumpy, jittery, less than luxurious performer.

Story continues below advertisement

This new V-6, however, is modern and willing, right down to its continuously variable valve timing. This six replaces both engine choices from 2011; it is the standard engine for all SRX models and it's a good one – with peak torque arriving at a quite low 2,400 rpm.

Some might argue the Caddy's six-speed automatic – even with its driver-selectable Eco feature – falls short of the seven-speeds in, say the FX and ML, and that's a fair quibble. But in refinement and output, the Caddy is right there in the game – and bests the V-6 in the Lexus (270 hp/248 lb-ft).

Where the SRX goes entirely its own direction, however, is in the design. Up front is what Caddy calls a "multi-piece shield grille" with vertical headlamps – headlights with adaptive lighting that aims the lamps in the direction of the front wheels. The sheetmetal is edgy and angular and like nothing else. This crossover has a wide stance, minimal overhangs front and rear, and wheels pushed to the corners. All together, the SRX has presence, right down to the 20-inch wheels that were standard on my Premium tester.

Inside, the cabin is modern and racy, right down to the front door sills that light up Cadillac script logos when you open the front doors. The audio and navigation system has voice recognition and in the Premium model includes Bose 5.1 surround sound with 10 speakers, a 40-gig hard drive and USB with audio connectivity. The Premium model's automatic climate control is managed by simple, effective controls and there is a useful driver information system that is standard on all models.

My big criticism of the cabin is the leather seat surfacings. The leather is smooth and almost slippery, which means that when you roll hard into a corner, you are inclined to slide around a bit. But at least you want to hit those corners.

That's because the SRX's four-wheel independent suspension system and standard rack-and-pinion hydraulic steering system – hydraulic, not electric! – makes for a tight handling package. While the SRX has a tall stance, in most respects this crossover handles more like a sporty sedan. Just in case, the list of standard fare ranges from stability control to airbags everywhere and a rearview camera system.

Story continues below advertisement

There's a lot here, so a last question: why isn't the SRX on more radar screens?

Tech specs

2012 Cadillac SRX Premium AWD

Type: Mid-size premium SUV

Base price: $54,740 ($1,595 freight)

Engine: 3.6-litre V-6

Horsepower/torque: 308 hp/265 lb-ft

Transmission: Six-speed automatic

Drive: All-wheel

Fuel economy (litres/100 km): 13.2 city/8.8 highway; regular gas

Alternatives: Infiniti FX, Lexus RX, Acura MDX, BMW X3 and X5, Mercedes-Benz ML and GLK, Audi Q5, Lincoln MKX, Volvo XC60 and XC90

jcato@globeandmail.com

Report an error
About the Author
Senior writer, Globe Drive

In 25 years of covering the auto industry, Jeremy Cato has won more than two-dozen awards, including three times being named automotive journalist of the year. Jeremy was born in Montreal and grew up in the San Francisco Bay Area. More

Comments

The Globe invites you to share your views. Please stay on topic and be respectful to everyone. For more information on our commenting policies and how our community-based moderation works, please read our Community Guidelines and our Terms and Conditions.

We’ve made some technical updates to our commenting software. If you are experiencing any issues posting comments, simply log out and log back in.

Discussion loading… ✨

Combined Shape Created with Sketch.

Combined Shape Created with Sketch.

Thank you!

You are now subscribed to the newsletter at

You can unsubscribe from this newsletter or Globe promotions at any time by clicking the link at the bottom of the newsletter, or by emailing us at privacy@globeandmail.com.