Skip to main content

The Globe and Mail

'Conditioned hypereating' may lower junk-food resistance

Food hijacked David Kessler's brain.

Not apples or carrots. The scientist who once led the U.S. government's attack on addictive cigarettes can't wander through one part of San Francisco without craving a local shop's chocolate-covered pretzels. Stop at one cookie? Rarely.

It's not an addiction but it's similar, and he's far from alone. Dr. Kessler's research suggests millions share what he calls "conditioned hypereating" - a willpower-sapping drive to eat high-fat, high-sugar foods even when they're not hungry.

Story continues below advertisement

In a book being published next week, the former U.S. Food and Drug Administration chief brings to consumers the disturbing conclusion of numerous brain studies: Some people really do have a harder time resisting bad foods. It's a new way of looking at the obesity epidemic that could help spur fledgling movements to reveal calories on restaurant menus or rein in portion sizes.

"The food industry has figured out what works. They know what drives people to keep on eating," Dr. Kessler said in an interview. "It's the next great public health campaign, of changing how we view food, and the food industry has to be part of it."

He says the culprits are foods "layered and loaded" with combinations of fat, sugar and salt - and often so processed that you don't even have to chew much.

Overeaters must take responsibility, too, and basically retrain their brains to resist the lure, he cautions.

"I have suits in every size," Dr. Kessler writes in The End of Overeating. But "once you know what's driving your behaviour, you can put steps into place" to change it.

At issue is how the brain becomes primed by different stimuli. Neuroscientists increasingly report that fat and sugar combinations in particular light up the brain's dopamine pathway - its pleasure-sensing spot - the same pathway that conditions people to alcohol or drugs.

Where did you experience the yum factor? That's the cue, sparking the brain to say, "I want that again," as you drive by a restaurant or plop before the TV.

Story continues below advertisement

"You're not even aware you've learned this," says Nora Volkow, chief of the National Institute on Drug Abuse and an authority on dopamine who has long studied similarities between drug addiction and obesity.

Dr. Volkow is a confessed chocoholic who salivates just walking past her laboratory's vending machine. "You have to fight it and fight it," she said.

Conditioning isn't always to blame. Numerous factors including physical activity, metabolism and hormones play a role in obesity.

And the food industry points out that increasingly stores and restaurants are giving consumers healthier choices, from allowing substitutions of fruit for French fries to selling packaged foods with less fat and salt.

But Dr. Kessler, now at the University of California, San Francisco, gathered colleagues to help build on that science and learn why some people have such a hard time choosing healthier foods:

First, the team found that even well-fed rats will work increasingly hard for sips of a vanilla milkshake with the right fat-sugar combo, and that adding sugar steadily increases consumption. Many low-fat foods substitute sugar for the removed fat, doing nothing to help dieters, Dr. Kessler and University of Washington researchers concluded.

Story continues below advertisement

Then, Dr. Kessler culled data from a major study on food habits and health. Conditioned hypereaters reported feeling loss of control over food and a lack of satiety, and were preoccupied by food. About 42 per cent were obese compared with 18 per cent of people without those behaviours, Dr. Kessler says.

Finally, Yale University neuroscientist Dana Small had hypereaters smell chocolate and taste a chocolate milkshake inside a brain-scanning MRI machine. Rather than getting used to the aroma, as is normal, hypereaters found the smell more tantalizing with time. And drinking the milkshake didn't satisfy them. The reward-anticipating region of their brains stayed switched on, so that another brain area couldn't say: "Enough."

People who aren't overweight can be conditioned hypereaters, too, Dr. Kessler found - so it is possible to control.

Take Dr. Volkow, the chocolate-loving neuroscientist. She's lean, and a self-described compulsive exerciser. Physical activity targets the dopamine pathway, too.

Dr. Kessler advises people to retrain the brain to think, "I'll hate myself if I eat that."

Lay down new neural reward circuits by substituting something else you enjoy, like a bike ride or a healthier food, he says.

Make rules to resist temptation: "I'm going to the mall but bypassing the food court."

And avoid cues for bad eating whenever possible. Always go for the nachos at your friends' weekend gathering spot? Start fresh at another restaurant.

"I've learned to eat things I like, but things I can control," Dr. Kessler says. But he knows the old circuitry dies hard: "You stress me enough and I'll go pick up that bagel."

Report an error

The Globe invites you to share your views. Please stay on topic and be respectful to everyone. For more information on our commenting policies and how our community-based moderation works, please read our Community Guidelines and our Terms and Conditions.

We’ve made some technical updates to our commenting software. If you are experiencing any issues posting comments, simply log out and log back in.

Discussion loading… ✨

Combined Shape Created with Sketch.

Combined Shape Created with Sketch.

Thank you!

You are now subscribed to the newsletter at

You can unsubscribe from this newsletter or Globe promotions at any time by clicking the link at the bottom of the newsletter, or by emailing us at