Skip to main content

The Globe and Mail

B.C. Liberals try to corner NDP on Mulcair's 'Dutch Disease' comments

Western premiers are expected to roundly condemn Thomas Mulcair's position on resource extraction when they meet this week, but B.C.'s governing Liberals are finding there might be something to love in the federal NDP Leader's controversial statements.

The B.C. Liberals, badly lagging behind the provincial NDP in the polls a year before next May's provincial election, introduced a resolution in the legislature Monday clearly aimed at painting the opposition into a corner.

"Be it resolved that this house unanimously reject the position stated by Thomas Mulcair that resource extraction in western provinces is bad for Canada," stated the motion, introduced by Liberal Bill Bennett, who sits on the party's re-election committee.

Story continues below advertisement

"We support resource extraction because of all the great jobs that it provides here in British Columbia," Mr. Bennett told the legislature.

"I'm trying to be as sensitive as I can because I'm trying to be as fair as I can to the Opposition."

NDP House Leader John Horgan initially balked at having the motion debated, but later said Mr. Mulcair's argument had been repeatedly misrepresented.

Mr. Mulcair has suggested Alberta oil exports raise the value of the Canadian dollar, which in turn hurts the economy in other parts of the country.

The phenomenon is dubbed "Dutch Disease" — a reference to the manufacturing decline that occurred in the Netherlands after a boom in natural gas exports in the 1970s.

Mr. Mulcair immediately came under vigorous criticism from the federal Conservatives, who have accused him of pitting east and west.

Saskatchewan Premier Brad Wall has also had harsh words for Mr. Mulcair and Alberta Premier Alison Redford has said she won't meet with Mr. Mulcair until he visits the Fort McMurray region to educate himself about the oil sands.

Story continues below advertisement

That visit is scheduled for Wednesday and Thursday.

Mr. Bennett said B.C. created 20,000 new net jobs last month because the government is pro-development and pro-trade.

"We're not ashamed to say that," he said.

"This is a glorious opportunity for the Opposition to stand and explain what their policies are on resource extraction and disavow themselves from the statements made by their federal ruler."

But the NDP noted Premier Christy Clark has been silent on the development of the Enbridge Northern Gateway expansion, although Mr. Redford and the federal government have touted it as a nationally important project.

The B.C. Liberals have steadfastly said they would await the outcome of year-long environmental hearings into the project.

Story continues below advertisement

"We know that First Nations in northern B.C. are unanimously opposed to this project, we know that local governments are opposed to this project, and we know that the premiers of Alberta and Ontario have made their views be known on this project," said New Democrat Doug Donaldson.

"Yet this government, the Premier, has not made her views be known on this project. She has not come out and said what she thinks of the project, whether it should go ahead or whether it should not go ahead, and that's just a lack of leadership."

NDP members argued Mr. Mulcair has been trying to make the point that he is against resource extraction that is not sustainable.

A clearly irritated Mr. Horgan accused the Liberals of "belligerence" and "McCarthyism" in bringing the motion forward. He accused a member of the Liberal caucus of having "too much wine for breakfast."

"No one on this side of the house rejects the notion of extracting and exploiting the bounty of natural resources here in British Columbia. Where we divide is, we want to add more value to that," Mr. Horgan said.

"Thomas Mulcair stood up and expressed a point of view, and in true Republican fashion, the B.C. Liberals saw an opportunity for what they call a wedge issue."

Liberal Pat Pimm, who represents the riding of Peace River North, said Mr. Mulcair's comments will be soundly rejected in northeast B.C., and he called the B.C. NDP, "Mr. Mulcair's puppet."

Report an error
Comments are closed

We have closed comments on this story for legal reasons. For more information on our commenting policies and how our community-based moderation works, please read our Community Guidelines and our Terms and Conditions.

Combined Shape Created with Sketch.

Combined Shape Created with Sketch.

Thank you!

You are now subscribed to the newsletter at

You can unsubscribe from this newsletter or Globe promotions at any time by clicking the link at the bottom of the newsletter, or by emailing us at