Skip to main content

Dustin Paxton is shown in a Calgary Police handout photo.

A Calgary judge has found Dustin Paxton guilty of the aggravated assault and sexual assault of a friend and roommate who was starved and beaten on a regular basis.



But Justice Sheilah Martin found Mr. Paxton not guilty of forcibly confining the man, who cannot be named because of a court-ordered publication ban.



Justice Martin said there was overwhelming evidence that Mr. Paxton abused the man. She said the victim could not consent to being a "whipping post."



"He treated the victim as his personal servant or bitch," Justice Martin said. "I find there is evidence of wounding, maiming, disfiguring and his life was in danger on two occasions."

She said she believed the victim's testimony that he performed sex acts on Mr. Paxton to appease him.



But Justice Martin said the victim had freedom of movement, meaning Mr. Paxton could not be convicted of holding the man against his will.



Mr. Paxton, who is 34, was charged in August 2010 — four months after a man he had shared a place with in Calgary was dropped off near death at a Regina hospital.



His trial began last Sept. 27 and moved at an agonizingly slow pace. The Crown called 43 witnesses in the proceedings, which took 4 1/2 months.



The 28-year-old alleged victim testified that he was starved, humiliated and beaten — sometimes severely — on an almost daily basis and forced to perform sexual favours for Mr. Paxton.



He testified that he took the abuse because he didn't want to appear to be "a sissy" and had dreams of making big money in Calgary through the business he and Mr. Paxton started.



He said he suffered severe facial trauma and had all of his ribs broken in a beating with a two-by-four.



The defence argued that the alleged victim was not tied up or locked in his room and could have left at any time.



The Crown brought in Kris Mohandie, a U.S.-based human captivity expert, who told court that the man reacted to the almost daily beatings like an abused pet or battered spouse and couldn't flee the relationship.



Monday's ruling began with Justice Martin rejecting the defence's request of a stay of proceedings.



Mr. Paxton's lawyer had argued that the case against his client should be thrown out because evidence showed a police officer coaching a witness.



But Justice Martin said that "almost all of the defence claims are not made out in the facts."



She then found Mr. Paxton guilty of assault on another man, a former employee who testified at his trial.



Justice Martin said she believed Abraham Chutta was threatened and whipped with a dog leash.



Mr. Chutta was one of the major witnesses supporting allegations that Mr. Paxton assaulted the roommate.



"I find Mr. Chutta to be a truthful and credible witness," Justice Martin said.



Mr. Chutta testified that he also lived with the accused and helped him and the victim set up their business. Mr. Chutta said Paxton would often fly into a rage over very small things.



The judicial stay of proceedings requested by defence lawyer Jim Lutz was one reason for the drawn-out affair. The application didn't come until after final arguments by Mr. Lutz and prosecutor Joe Mercier.



Mr. Lutz said in his application that his client hadn't received a fair trial because there was evidence that showed police coaching a witness who was called to testify against Mr. Paxton.



The application resulted in a fresh set of lawyers brought in to argue for and against the stay, which, if granted, would have allowed Mr. Paxton to walk free.



Both Mr. Lutz and Mr. Mercier found themselves in the unusual position of being called as witnesses. The defence lawyer testified that two different spectators approached him to report that they saw a senior Calgary police officer coaching a witness from the gallery and that a court clerk reported seeing the same thing.



Mr. Lutz also testified that he had asked that a key witness who had an outstanding warrant be arrested, but the court's sheriff was told by the Crown not to make the arrest.

Interact with The Globe