Skip to main content

The Globe and Mail

Stéphane Dion’s stance on China confusing, out of step with Liberals, critics say

Foreign Affairs Minister Stéphane Dion sowed confusion and showcased cracks in Liberal ranks when he angrily denied recently that negotiations are under way on an extradition treaty with China, critics say.

Fred Lum/The Globe and Mail

Foreign Affairs Minister Stéphane Dion sowed confusion and showcased cracks in Liberal ranks when he angrily denied recently that negotiations are under way on an extradition treaty with China, critics say.

One federal official said that Mr. Dion was simply flustered about semantics when he denied the launch of talks: "Preliminary discussions are a precursor to negotiations and those discussions have only just begun."

Still, another senior Liberal added: "I'm not clear what [Mr. Dion] was trying to say."

Story continues below advertisement

Read more: Dion denies extradition treaty negotiations with China

Read more: China's Fox Hunt in Canada strains trust that an extradition treaty is possible

Read more: Justin Trudeau defends extradition treaty talks with China

In a telephone interview with The Globe and Mail on Friday, Mr. Dion insisted there are no negotiations in the works that could see Canada return Chinese fugitives accused of economic crimes.

"Your paper should check the facts. There is no negotiation. To write like pretending it is, it is wrong. Stop that please," Mr. Dion said.

When asked what kinds of specific guarantees the Canadian government would demand with a formal Chinese extradition treaty, Mr. Dion again became testy. "We never extradite people to countries who have the death penalty. Your question is unfair because never the government of Canada would do such a thing. And why you are implying that is beyond me. That's my answer to your question."

However, Canada has returned more than 1,400 Chinese nationals since 2009, most of whom were involved in illegal immigration. In addition, Canada has an extradition treaty with the United States, although Ottawa insists on receiving assurances that people will not face the death penalty if they are sent back to face the American justice system.

Story continues below advertisement

Conservative MP Peter Kent said the Liberals are all over the map in terms of Canada's relationship with China, as Ottawa enters into talks on free trade, justice issues and cybersecurity with Beijing.

"I think there is a disagreement in the Liberal caucus on this," Mr. Kent said in an interview.

Alex Neve, Amnesty International Canada's secretary-general, said Mr. Dion is a clear opponent of the death penalty and setting clear benchmarks for the talks.

"There have been differing views and different understandings expressed by different members of the government," Mr. Neve said. "I have no doubt that Mr. Dion's take on this would be that he would not countenance an extradition treaty that is going to give rise to concerns about the death penalty."

Mr. Trudeau defended the extradition-treaty negotiations during a joint news conference with Chinese Premier Li Keqiang and in the House a few days ago, saying it was part of Ottawa's goal to rebuild the relationship with China.

Formal talks were agreed to on Sept. 12 during high-level talks between Mr. Trudeau's national security adviser, Daniel Jean, and a top Chinese Communist Party official.

Story continues below advertisement

Mr. Trudeau said the government understood the difficulties in negotiating an extradition treaty with China. "We recognize that Canada and China have different systems of law and order and different approaches and it'll be very important that any future agreement be based on reflecting the realities, the principles, the values that our citizens hold dear in each of our countries," he said alongside Mr. Li.

During the news conference, the Premier publicly urged Mr. Trudeau to sign a formal extradition treaty to seek the return of Chinese fugitives, adding that 40 other countries, including France and Australia, have signed such deals.

While Mr. Li said critics are wrongly disparaging China's justice system as being based on torture, repression and coercion, he argued that the death penalty is still needed to deal with violent crime. Thousands of executions take place in China annually for crimes ranging from fraud to murder.

Mr. Trudeau, who disavowed the use of the death penalty in any circumstances, said humanitarian treatment must be applied in any future agreements.

On social media on Saturday, Mr. Trudeau's principal secretary, Gerald Butts, said the visit of Mr. Li was the culmination of six months of work, aimed at resetting the China-Canada relationship on a "much stronger, stable footing."

"Lots of tricky water to navigate in the future, but a great start," Mr. Butts wrote.

Report an error Licensing Options
About the Author
Parliamentary reporter

Daniel Leblanc studied political science at the University of Ottawa and journalism at Carleton University. He became a full-time reporter in 1998, first at the Ottawa Citizen and then in the Ottawa bureau of The Globe and Mail. More

Comments

The Globe invites you to share your views. Please stay on topic and be respectful to everyone. For more information on our commenting policies and how our community-based moderation works, please read our Community Guidelines and our Terms and Conditions.

We’ve made some technical updates to our commenting software. If you are experiencing any issues posting comments, simply log out and log back in.

Discussion loading… ✨

Combined Shape Created with Sketch.

Combined Shape Created with Sketch.

Thank you!

You are now subscribed to the newsletter at

You can unsubscribe from this newsletter or Globe promotions at any time by clicking the link at the bottom of the newsletter, or by emailing us at privacy@globeandmail.com.