Skip to main content

The Globe and Mail

Senate Speaker challenges Mulcair’s expenses in departure from neutral role

Speaker of the Senate Noel Kinsella speaks with the media in Ottawa on Dec. 2, 2013.


The Speaker of the Senate is directly challenging NDP Leader Tom Mulcair, an unheard-of step for the normally neutral referee of the Red Chamber.

Noel Kinsella has issued an unprecedented statement blasting Mulcair for accusing him of claiming improper living expenses.

The Conservative Speaker's missive came several hours after Mulcair told the House of Commons that Kinsella and Liberal Senator Pierrette Ringuette "pulled the exact same trick as Mike Duffy" – one of four disgraced senators under RCMP investigation for allegedly defrauding the Senate.

Story continues below advertisement

Kinsella says he and Ringuette, both senators from New Brunswick, are entitled to claim reimbursement for their accommodations in Ottawa – as are New Democrat MPs whose home ridings are more than 100 kilometres from the national capital region.

He says Mulcair's "unfounded personal attack" against him and Ringuette amounts to an attack on his own NDP members.

And he suggests Mulcair, who lives in the taxpayer-provided official Opposition Leader's residence, is in no position to criticize parliamentarians who must keep a secondary residence in the capital.

"[Mulcair] lives for free in a lovely house in upscale Rockcliffe Park, at Stornoway," Kinsella said in the statement, issued late Wednesday.

"While Thomas Mulcair as leader of the Opposition is given a house in Ottawa, the leader of the government in the Senate, the leader of the Opposition in the Senate and the Speaker of the Senate all must make their own housing arrangements in Ottawa, which is done through the common accommodation rules applicable to senators and MPs."

He added that Mulcair's views on the Senate are well known, inferring that the accusation against him and Ringuette was motivated by the NDP leader's determination to abolish the Red Chamber.

Kinsella's extraordinary intervention was sparked by Question Period in the Commons earlier Wednesday, when Mulcair questioned why Kinsella and Ringuette have not been suspended from the Senate as have Duffy and two other senators who allegedly made improper expense claims.

Story continues below advertisement

"Conservative Senator Noel Kinsella and Liberal Senator Pierrette Ringuette pulled the exact same trick as Mike Duffy – the trick that, on Oct. 24, the Prime Minister said was the reason for getting rid of Mike Duffy," Mulcair said.

"Why are Noel Kinsella and Pierrette Ringuette still in the Senate?"

Harper defended both senators as "longtime residents" of New Brunswick, unlike Duffy who claimed his longtime Ottawa home as a secondary residence and a little-used cottage in Prince Edward Island as his primary home.

Both Kinsella and Ringuette owned homes in Ottawa, as well as New Brunswick, before their appointment to the Senate.

Wednesday's missive marks the second time this week that Kinsella has broken with precedent.

On Monday, he held an extraordinary, hour-long news conference in the Senate chamber. He fielded questions about the Senate expenses scandal but also provided a history lesson on the value of having a second parliamentary chamber of sober second thought.

Story continues below advertisement

During that session, Kinsella disclosed that he pays taxes in New Brunswick and holds a driver's licence and health card from that province – all criteria used by the Senate's internal economy committee in determining primary residency.

He also pointed out that the Speaker of the Senate is not quite as neutral or non-partisan as the Speaker of the Commons. The Senate Speaker may join in debate and vote on bills and motions, unlike his Commons counterpart who may vote only to break a tie and doesn't participate in debate.

Moreover, Kinsella said he attends Conservative national caucus meetings, whereas the Commons Speaker does not.

Report an error

The Globe invites you to share your views. Please stay on topic and be respectful to everyone. For more information on our commenting policies and how our community-based moderation works, please read our Community Guidelines and our Terms and Conditions.

We’ve made some technical updates to our commenting software. If you are experiencing any issues posting comments, simply log out and log back in.

Discussion loading… ✨

Combined Shape Created with Sketch.

Combined Shape Created with Sketch.

Thank you!

You are now subscribed to the newsletter at

You can unsubscribe from this newsletter or Globe promotions at any time by clicking the link at the bottom of the newsletter, or by emailing us at