Skip to main content

George Smitherman

Age: 46

In the polls: 40.5 per cent*

Story continues below advertisement

Last seen:

As deputy premier and energy and infrastructure minister, bulldog to Dalton McGuinty's Premier Dad. Mr. Smitherman credits himself with the province's Green Energy Act, which creates built-in subsidies for renewable energy. His critics also credit the former health minister with the "billion-dollar boondoggle" that was e-Health.

Quote he wants you to remember:

"I'm a man with a plan. … It's time for Toronto to get its groove back."

Feature film in the works? We hope so.

Quote he doesn't want you to remember:

"I don't negotiate with terrorists."

Story continues below advertisement

Taliban? FLQ? Nope: Optometrists fighting cuts in health-insurance coverage. (Then-health minister, Mr. Smitherman later apologized for the statement.)

Campaign high point:

The good news: Hundreds of starry-eyed supporters, enthused to the point of incoherence, have crammed themselves into a chic College Street resto-lounge, chanting his name as he gets a ringing endorsement from Liberal all-star Justin Trudeau.

The bad news: The fire marshal's coming. And the supporters are sweaty.

Low point:

After taking months of flak for running a cagey frontrunner's campaign, there's nothing like waking up to phone calls asking you why you're trailing in the polls by 24 percentage points.

Story continues below advertisement

Wake-up call, Mr. Smitherman? Try "evacuation siren."

Where he stands on...


Light rail and subways to the suburbs: Mr. Smitherman would keep most of Transit City, but add to the edges - Downsview, Sherway Gardens, the Port Lands, the University of Toronto's Scarborough campus, the Woodbine Centre and Weston Road.

Reality check:

The money's not there: Mr. Smitherman's transit plan relies on $5-billion in debt over several years.


Freeze property taxes for a year, save $61-million a year by only replacing two-thirds of employees who retire and sell the city's minority stake in Enwave. Give seniors free rides on transit and spend $10-million on programs for youth employment.

Reality check:

2011 budget depends on $100-million from the province for which the city doesn't yet have a commitment. Like Mr. Ford, he relies (albeit not as heavily) on savings from attrition to make his fiscal plan work.


Has promised to localize city decision-making, pursuing "community-based planning" and appointing neighbourhood councils of unelected residents and business owners, although it's not clear how much decision-making power they would have.

Reality check:

All the candidates have tried to tap into lingering dissatisfaction with a post-amalgamation Toronto. But the risk of hyper-local councils, observers warn, is that they'll balkanize neighbourhoods and render the city incapable of functioning as a single entity.


Centrist clout. Mr. Smitherman has sought to model himself as a progressive who's into "city-building" but isn't afraid to get tough when it comes to balancing the city's books.

Fatal weakness:

Mystery man. A year into his candidacy, many voters are still trying to figure out what this guy stands for.

* Based on figures from a Nanos Research poll of 1,000 very likely Toronto voters conducted Oct. 14-16.

Report an error Licensing Options
Comments are closed

We have closed comments on this story for legal reasons. For more information on our commenting policies and how our community-based moderation works, please read our Community Guidelines and our Terms and Conditions.

Combined Shape Created with Sketch.

Combined Shape Created with Sketch.

Thank you!

You are now subscribed to the newsletter at

You can unsubscribe from this newsletter or Globe promotions at any time by clicking the link at the bottom of the newsletter, or by emailing us at