Skip to main content

The Globe and Mail

Stintz plans to shut down TTC subsidiary created by mayor

Karen Stintz

Fred Lum/The Globe and Mail/Fred Lum/The Globe and Mail

One of the first acts of Toronto's new transit commission will be to kill off a shell corporation the Ford administration established to chase its dream of a Sheppard subway extension.

TTC chair Karen Stintz wants to begin winding down Toronto Transit Infrastructure Ltd., a now-penniless TTC subsidiary, when a freshly appointed slate of pro-LRT commissioners meets at the end of this month.

"I think there's a question of whether it needs to exist any longer and whether we couldn't just wrap up that entity," Ms. Stintz said.

Story continues below advertisement

TTIL ran out of money last summer, leaving it unable to pay CEO Gordon Chong and the researcher he hired, along with three consultants provided by Metrolinx, the provincial transit authority for the Greater Toronto Area.

On top of that, The Globe and Mail has learned that TTIL used city money for a KPMG analysis of funding options for a Sheppard extension that cost $175,000 – more than all of the funds TTIL had in the bank.

"I believe that money was a misuse of taxpayers' dollars," said TTC commissioner Maria Augimeri, an opponent of Mayor Rob Ford.

Scrapping TTIL wouldn't end Mr. Ford's subway push. That decision rests with the province and city council, which is set to decide the Sheppard line's fate on March 21.

Still, the looming death of TTIL doesn't bode well for the Ford administration.

Toronto Transit Infrastructure Ltd. was created because the mayor's office didn't trust the TTC – which was already committed to David Miller's light-rail network – to pursue a private partnership for a Sheppard subway, Mr. Chong and Ms. Stintz say.

"We set up a working group with the TTC, but they were less than co-operative. I firmly believe, and it's been my experience with them, that the TTC has been unalterably opposed to partnering with the private sector," Mr. Chong said.

Story continues below advertisement

On March 8 of last year, Ms. Stintz, Mr. Chong, and councillors Peter Milczyn, Doug Ford and Norm Kelly were among a group that met in Mr. Kelly's office to revive a dormant subsidiary of the transit agency called Toronto Transit Consultants Ltd.

They renamed it Toronto Transit Infrastructure Ltd., and made Mr. Kelly, Councillor Ford and Mr. Chong a three-man board of directors. Mr. Chong, a retired city councillor and former GO Transit chairman, was appointed CEO.

"I didn't understand why they were meeting in a councillor's office," Ms. Augimeri said. "I didn't understand what they could be hiding behind the backs of the commissioners themselves … it's unheard of."

The TTC did make public minutes of the meeting in Mr. Kelly's office. Mr. Kelly didn't return calls seeking comment on Tuesday.

The newly christened subsidiary had just over $161,000 in the bank, money left over from the old consulting arm. Legal fees to set up TTIL burned through $45,207, and it wasn't long before Mr. Chong's $8,000-a-month salary and fees for his researcher, Joanne Kennelly, swallowed the rest.

Mr. Chong has gone unpaid since July. "I didn't take this job on for the money," he said. "I believe in subways … the Sheppard subway was started and it should be finished."

Story continues below advertisement

To that end, he kept working for free, submitting an initial application to P3 Canada, the federal fund that supports public-private infrastructure partnerships and publishing an interim report in favour of a Sheppard subway extension.

Mr. Chong's free labour wasn't enough; TTIL had to beg for cash elsewhere.

Through Metrolinx, it retained three consultants at a cost of $44,500 to complete a business-case analysis for four subway options on Sheppard.

Metrolinx has paid the trio of consultants and billed the city.

Next, TTIL asked the city to pick up the tab for a KPMG report on funding options for Sheppard. That cost $175,000, a city spokeswoman confirmed on Tuesday.

Finally, TTIL had to turn to the mayor's office budget to cover Ms. Kennelly's research fees in September and October at a cost of $31,640, including HST.

Considering how long TTIL has been starved of funds, Mr. Chong isn't surprised Ms. Stintz, who led a coup to sweep Mr. Ford's allies off the board last week, wants to shut it down.

But he said it would be a shame if the TTC abandoned TTIL's campaign for public-private partnership and a subway on Sheppard.

Report an error Licensing Options
About the Author
Health reporter

Kelly Grant is a health reporter with The Globe and Mail. More

Comments are closed

We have closed comments on this story for legal reasons. For more information on our commenting policies and how our community-based moderation works, please read our Community Guidelines and our Terms and Conditions.

Combined Shape Created with Sketch.

Combined Shape Created with Sketch.

Thank you!

You are now subscribed to the newsletter at

You can unsubscribe from this newsletter or Globe promotions at any time by clicking the link at the bottom of the newsletter, or by emailing us at privacy@globeandmail.com.