Skip to main content

The Globe and Mail

Mnuchin softens brazen U.S. trade talk in global stage debut

German Federal Finance Minister Wolfgang Schaeuble, left, and U.S. Treasury Secretary, Steven Mnuchin interact during a joint press conference in Berlin, Germany, Thursday, March 16, 2017. The U.S. and German finance chiefs say they are ready to co-operate and avoid ‘trade wars’.

Soeren Stache/AP

Treasury Secretary Steven Mnuchin may offer the Group of 20 something the world hasn't heard yet from the new U.S. administration on currency and trade policy: reassurance.

Mnuchin arrives Friday in Baden-Baden, Germany, for a meeting of G20 finance ministers and central bankers, during his first official trip abroad. There he'll run into international peers with sway over the world's biggest developed and emerging economies who are grappling with the uncertainty of the Trump administration's "America First" message.

In his first press conference since becoming Treasury chief last month, Mnuchin sat next to his German counterpart Thursday in Berlin and described his talks with Wolfgang Schaeuble as "extremely productive." Schaeuble was also complimentary, calling the discussion "a good start."

Story continues below advertisement

Mnuchin's diplomatic touch stood in stark contrast to other Trump administration officials who've called the U.S.'s $68-billion trade deficit with Germany an economic injustice that needs to be countered, taking a more confrontational tone. Mnuchin's measured approach may be seen as an emollient amid the often chaotic signaling by the new administration.

The new U.S. Treasury chief acknowledged the complexity underlying Germany's large trade imbalance and said the U.S. wants to avoid trade wars. While President Donald Trump and his advisers have claimed Germany is gaming foreign-exchange markets, the administration hasn't until now clarified its views, considering the nation is part of the 19-nation euro area.

"The euro is used by many countries and impacted by many aspects. It is a very different situation than we have: a single currency controlled by a single country," Mnuchin said.

Dollar Chief

While stewarding currency policy has traditionally been the job of the Treasury secretary, comments from Commerce Secretary Wilbur Ross, Trump's top trade adviser, and the president himself have left the world to wonder who is really driving that policy.

"They should listen to the president first and listen to me as well," Mnuchin said when asked who is the U.S. spokesman on the dollar. Sticking to his message, he said that the Treasury Department will use a regular review of foreign-exchange markets to examine whether any nation should be designated a currency manipulator.

The 54-year-old Mnuchin, a political newcomer, will use his first G20 meeting to urge counterparts to follow through on their commitment to refrain from competitive currency devaluations, a senior Treasury official said in a briefing on Monday in Washington.

Story continues below advertisement

The counterpart to the U.S.'s currency stance is trade policy, and while that's not the specialty of the central bank governors and finance ministers in the G20, a consensus on that topic is normally reflected in all of their statements – unless there is none.

Germany, which hosts the G20 presidency this year, was rebuffed in its attempts to forge a compromise on the wording of a statement about the global economy that reflects the rules-led system under the World Trade Organization, and the focus on "fairness" that the new U.S. spirit has brought with it.

G20 Club

The challenge for Mnuchin will be to square the Trump administration's threats of tariffs for trade cheaters and inward-looking economic policies with the cooperative spirit the G20 has operated under for years. The club of the world's key economies has, until now, mostly stressed agreement on rules-based trade, open markets and predictable monetary policy.

EU Commissioner Pierre Moscovici said in a Bloomberg TV interview in Baden-Baden on Friday that he believes Mnuchin wants to show the U.S. is involved in multilateral institutions. The Italian and French finance ministers want to go further.

"I hope there will be a wide agreement on the benefits of a global, open system based on rules and multilateralism," Italy's Pier Carlo Padoan told reporters.

Story continues below advertisement

"What is sure is that the G20 is dedicated to multilateralism and international cooperation," France's Michel Sapin said. "We at the G20, the rest of the world, aren't in favor of protectionism, in fact are anti-protectionism. We are for a free, regulated international trade, with rules respected by everyone."

Mnuchin wasn't sounding like a hardened trade protectionist on Thursday.

"We both believe it is important for the U.S. to play an essential leadership role towards global economic growth," he said sitting next to Schaeuble. "We also both feel it's very important to work together to unleash growth, stimulate job creation, and work cooperatively on balanced trade across the economies."

Fair Trade

Deputies to the G20 finance chiefs concluded the draft communique on Thursday that will be discussed by the ministers and central bank governors, who can still make changes.

Negotiators from countries including France, the U.K., Italy, Brazil and Singapore – as well as the European Commission – were against a proposal that dropped a G20 commitment to "multilateral" and "rule-based" trade in the policy statement, a person familiar with the matter said, asking not to be named because the proceedings are private. The U.S. had requested the changes, and asked that a reference to "fair" international trade to be included.

In the G20's attempt to accommodate the new U.S. administration, it could be readying to drop a commitment that last year had been critical – the pledge to resist "all forms of protectionism." That could be just wording – or it could be the signal of a new era in the global economy in response to Trump's focus on bilateral trade deals and the America First stance.

"The muscular rhetoric of getting better trade deals and bilateral deals may work very well politically, the question is whether or not it is ever going to lead to some actual deals, accomplishments on the trade front," said Kevin Madden, partner at Hamilton Place Strategies, said on a panel on Frankfurt on Thursday.

"A lot of what of this administration does is try to draw a contrast with they believe was the wrong direction of the past eight years, which was globalism."

Report an error

The Globe invites you to share your views. Please stay on topic and be respectful to everyone. For more information on our commenting policies and how our community-based moderation works, please read our Community Guidelines and our Terms and Conditions.

We’ve made some technical updates to our commenting software. If you are experiencing any issues posting comments, simply log out and log back in.

Discussion loading… ✨

Combined Shape Created with Sketch.

Combined Shape Created with Sketch.

Thank you!

You are now subscribed to the newsletter at

You can unsubscribe from this newsletter or Globe promotions at any time by clicking the link at the bottom of the newsletter, or by emailing us at