Skip to main content

The Globe and Mail

A Good Day kicks off Australian mining magnate’s horse sale

An auctioneer’s assistant gestures to a bidder at the Magic Millions sales complex on Australia’s Gold Coast Oct. 30, 2012.


With a cry of "cheap as old boots" from the auctioneer, the hammer came down at A$5,000 ($5,200) on the first broodmare to open a three-day auction of 350 horses from the stables of faltering mining magnate Nathan Tinkler.

Mr. Tinkler's rise from pit electrician to Australia's youngest billionaire has hit a hurdle, with creditors circling his stable of mining, sports and racing businesses, and he is raising funds with the out-of-season sale that began on Tuesday.

His 19.4-per-cent stake in Australia's biggest independent coal miner Whitehaven Coal Ltd., which represents the bulk of his wealth, is heavily leveraged and has shrunk considerably in line with falling coal prices.

Story continues below advertisement

A fiery annual general meeting looms as the next hurdle on Thursday, with Mr. Tinkler demanding a clear earnings forecast from Whitehaven and threatening to use his voting power to overthrow the chairman and senior board members if they don't comply.

Mr. Tinkler, 36, fulfilled his dream of owning a racing stable, joining a business known as "the sport of kings" and its wealthy elite, after he turned a A$1-million bet on an unfancied coal deposit into a billion-dollar fortune.

However his Whitehaven stake, worth about $1.2-billion at its peak, has shrunk to below A$700-million. Sources have told Reuters Mr. Tinkler is dealing with a number of lawsuits over missed payments.

But Tuesday started with a good omen – the first horse on the block was named A Good Day. Many punters at the blood stock auction company Magic Millions said prices at Mr. Tinkler's "unreserved reduction sale" were higher than anticipated.

"I couldn't be happier with the way the market is and the way it has received the stock we are selling," said Magic Millions managing director Vin Cox. Buyers were mainly from Australia, with some from the Philippines.

Prices for the 200 mares on sale on Tuesday from Tinkler's Patinack Farm, ranged from A$1,000 to A$240,000, pulling in more than A$2.5-million near the end of the first day.

Brian Nutt, owner of the Attunga Stud, said prices were higher than he anticipated given that Mr. Tinkler's "C-grade" stock was on the block, but still well down on what would be expected at the industry's two annual broodmare sales.

Story continues below advertisement

"The quality of this sale is certainly not as good," Mr. Nutt said, clutching a dog-eared catalogue after deciding not to bid on a mare.

Mr. Tinkler's foray into horses has been as eventful as his investment in mining, splashing out more than A$300-million since 2007 to build Patinack Farm, Australia's largest thoroughbred racing and stud operation.

The spending spree included A$19-million on 59 horses at the 2008 Magic Millions annual yearling sale. Mr. Tinkler's two stud farms in New South Wales state and a third in neighbouring Queensland are home to more than 1,200 horses.

"I've always been a fan of the horses and stuff and I suppose it's probably got a bit out of hand, but it's good fun and I enjoy it," Mr. Tinkler said in a rare TV interview last year.

He celebrated when stallion All Too Hard won the Caulfield Guineas two weeks ago, but other winners have been scarce.

"Most people in the industry believe he has built up too quickly," one bloodstock manager, who asked not to be identified, said at Tuesday's sale.

Story continues below advertisement

Australian media have also reported that Mr. Tinkler tried to offload his entire racing business at a loss to a Qatari sheik.

"It's not a good time to sell mares," said Peter Ford, the manager of Peter Ford Thoroughbreds, who was almost drowned out by the rapid-fire patter of the auctioneer. "All of us know this is a sale of the bottom, a lot of serious buyers aren't here."

Patinack Farm representatives have said the timing was right for a reduction of its bloodstock, even though broodmares are usually sold at Easter, rather than the current breeding season.

Mr. Nutt, his eye still open for a Patinack bargain, said the racing industry was grateful for Mr. Tinkler's splurge.

"He propped up the industry at a difficult time," Mr. Nutt said. A lot of breeders have done very well out of him."

Report an error

The Globe invites you to share your views. Please stay on topic and be respectful to everyone. For more information on our commenting policies and how our community-based moderation works, please read our Community Guidelines and our Terms and Conditions.

We’ve made some technical updates to our commenting software. If you are experiencing any issues posting comments, simply log out and log back in.

Discussion loading… ✨