Skip to main content

The Globe and Mail

SAP falls short of expectations, drops behind arch-rival Oracle

The headquarters of German software maker SAP in Walldorf near Heidelberg are shown in this file photo.


Quarterly earnings from SAP AG fell short of expectations on Tuesday, showing the German business software maker failed to keep up with arch-rival Oracle Corp. and sending its shares sharply lower.

SAP's results, released more than a week before they had been scheduled, showed group revenue rose 12 per cent to €5.06-billion ($6.8-billion U.S.), below an average analyst forecast of €5.17-billion, according to Reuters data.

Operating profit rose more slowly than revenue, gaining 10 per cent to €1.96-billion, resulting in SAP's operating margin narrowing by 0.8 percentage points to 38.8 per cent in the three months through December.

Story continues below advertisement

The figures contrasted with those of Oracle, the world's No. 3 software maker and SAP's biggest competitor, which last month forecast strong sales for 2013 after posting a 17-per-cent jump in quarterly software revenue.

SAP shares were down 3.8 per cent and were the biggest decliners in a 2-per-cent weaker sector index by mid-afternoon. The stock fell as low as €57.77, its lowest in two months.

"Especially after their main competitor Oracle managed to beat estimates last month, many had hoped that SAP would follow suit," said Markus Huber, head of German trading at ETX Capital.

"Even by missing estimates by a very small margin, and despite having had an overall excellent 2012, investors are venting their disappointment by dumping the stock heavily," Mr. Huber added.

SAP said its operating profit was affected by investments in web-based software products, also known as "cloud" businesses.

The Walldorf, southern Germany-based company, along with peers such as International Business Machines Corp. (IBM) and Oracle, are betting on faster-growing, web-based software products, which are less vulnerable to the economic downturn as there are no upfront costs for program licences, dedicated hardware or installation.

SAP last year splashed out $7.7-billion to buy Internet-based computing companies Ariba and SuccessFactors.

Story continues below advertisement

The web-based services garnered just €342-million in 2012 revenues, a fraction of the total €16.3-billion.

With a market capitalization of $100-billion, SAP is the second-most valuable company in the German blue chip index behind Volkswagen AG, which is worth $105-billion, according to Reuters data.

SAP is due to publish full financial results and a full-year outlook on Jan. 23. Some analysts fear the 2013 outlook could also disappoint.

"Guidance could be slightly below current consensus and expectations may be revised lower," Barclays analyst Gerardus Vos said in a note.

SAP's full-year operating profit at constant currencies reached €5.02-billion, missing its own guidance for at least €5.05-billion.

Report an error

The Globe invites you to share your views. Please stay on topic and be respectful to everyone. For more information on our commenting policies and how our community-based moderation works, please read our Community Guidelines and our Terms and Conditions.

We’ve made some technical updates to our commenting software. If you are experiencing any issues posting comments, simply log out and log back in.

Discussion loading… ✨