Skip to main content

The Globe and Mail

U.S. NAFTA demands on auto rules of origin could backfire, experts say

The Magna plant in Puebla, Mexico on Wednesday, January 22, 2015.

Brett Gundlock/Boreal Collective/The Globe and Mail

U.S. demands that a new NAFTA deal include stronger rules of origin and a minimum amount of U.S. content in North America-built vehicles could backfire on the United States, auto industry officials and trade experts say.

U.S. representatives kicked off negotiations on a new North American free-trade agreement Wednesday by making those auto industry proposals front and centre and pointing a finger at Mexico and the $68-billion (U.S.) surplus in automotive products that country is running with the United States.

But changing rules of origin so the requirement for North American content in vehicles exceeds the current level of 62.5 per cent and insisting on a set percentage of U.S. content could cause auto makers and parts companies to shift production outside NAFTA.

Story continues below advertisement

Opinion: The U.S. has a weak NAFTA hand on autos – Canada and Mexico should stay cool

Read More: NAFTA's first round of talks will jump right into Chapter 19

That would be the opposite effect of what the Trump administration is seeking in the NAFTA talks, which is to repatriate jobs that it believes have flooded out of the United States to Mexico, or at least divert any new automotive production away from its southern neighbour and to the United States instead.

What auto makers and parts suppliers could do is decide not to comply with rules that allow them to ship duty-free within NAFTA and instead subject themselves to the 2.5-per-cent tariff the United States levies on vehicles and parts imported from non-NAFTA countries.

"Changing rules of origin in a way that raises costs by 2.5 per cent or more could prompt auto makers to simply ignore the NAFTA market-access provisions, pay the 2.5-per-cent tariff and scrap the costly rules of origin documentation," said Dan Ciuriak, a former chief economist with the Department of Foreign Affairs and International Trade, who now heads Ciuriak Consulting Inc.

Auto companies could shift production to China and supply the U.S. market from there, Mr. Ciuriak said, as Ford Motor Co. will do with its Focus compact car after the Trump administration criticized the company for planning to build a new assembly plant in Mexico that would export Focus models to the United States.

If auto producers source their parts from offshore suppliers, that would cause cuts in assembly and parts jobs in the United States, Sandy Moroz, lead negotiator for Canada on rules of origin in the original NAFTA talks, said in a commentary for Policy Options.

Story continues below advertisement

"It backfires on the U.S.," said David Worts, executive director of the Japan Automobile Manufacturers Association of Canada. "If you're paying the [2.5-per-cent] tariff, you don't have to meet any rule."

Foreign Affairs Minister Chrystia Freeland quickly rejected the idea of national content, but appeared more flexible on rules of origin.

"It's going to be very important from the Canadian perspective to take very great care in any changes which are made to ensure they don't disrupt supply chains," Ms. Freeland told reporters in Washington on Wednesday after the first day of talks.

Comments on rules of origin and U.S. content in vehicles made Wednesday by U.S. Trade Representative Robert Lighthizer represented a major shift for Canadian negotiators, who had not been led to expect this demand from previous U.S. statements on NAFTA talks.

U.S. officials gave little indication before this week that they would demand U.S.-specific auto content rules.

In negotiating objectives released last month, the U.S. government repeatedly talked about ensuring that local-content rules help both the United States and North America, rather than merely aiding U.S. manufacturers.

Story continues below advertisement

The U.S. proposals run counter to the theme it has been hearing from the auto industry: do no harm.

In almost a quarter-century since NAFTA came into force in 1993, the industry has restructured itself along continental lines. Vehicles and components are manufactured in each of the three countries and cross borders duty-free and relatively seamlessly – in some cases, several times.

Parts that are labour-intensive, such as seat fabrics and wire harnesses, are made mainly in Mexico, where wages are about 10 per cent of the level they are in Canada and the United States.

"Forcing large-scale restructuring on the auto industry will involve significant costs for the producers and eventually consumers," Mr. Ciuriak said.

Video: McKenna says free trade benefits North American auto industry (The Canadian Press)
Report an error Licensing Options
About the Authors
Auto and Steel Industry Reporter

Greg Keenan has covered the automotive and steel industries for The Globe and Mail since 1995. He also writes about broader manufacturing trends. He is a graduate of the University of Toronto and of the University of Western Ontario School of Journalism. More

Parliamentary reporter

Steven Chase has covered federal politics in Ottawa for The Globe since mid-2001, arriving there a few months before 9/11. He previously worked in the paper's Vancouver and Calgary bureaus. Prior to that, he reported on Alberta politics for the Calgary Herald and the Calgary Sun, and on national issues for Alberta Report. More

Washington correspondent

Adrian Morrow covers U.S. politics from Washington, D.C. Previously he was The Globe's Ontario politics reporter. He's covered news, crime and sports for The Globe since 2010. He won the National Newspaper Award for politics reporting in 2016. More

Comments

The Globe invites you to share your views. Please stay on topic and be respectful to everyone. For more information on our commenting policies and how our community-based moderation works, please read our Community Guidelines and our Terms and Conditions.

We’ve made some technical updates to our commenting software. If you are experiencing any issues posting comments, simply log out and log back in.

Discussion loading… ✨

Combined Shape Created with Sketch.

Combined Shape Created with Sketch.

Thank you!

You are now subscribed to the newsletter at

You can unsubscribe from this newsletter or Globe promotions at any time by clicking the link at the bottom of the newsletter, or by emailing us at privacy@globeandmail.com.