Skip to main content

The Globe and Mail

Clock's ticking on goaltender choices

The biggest decision Brian Burke has to make between now and when the flag drops on the NHL's free-agent season at midnight on July 1 will be at goaltender.

Right now, the Toronto Maple Leafs general manager has made the easy decisions. Vesa Toskala, who becomes an unrestricted free agent, has as much chance of coming back as your agent does of being elected Miss America. Rookie Jonas Gustavsson will become a restricted free agent. He says he wants to stay with the Leafs and indications are that Burke feels the same, although contract negotiations have not started yet and this is not a lock.

Story continues below advertisement

The hard choice is one of three options:

Hand the No. 1 job to Gustavsson next season and sign a good backup from the list of free agents.

Look for a veteran free agent who can act as a mentor to the 25-year-old Gustavsson and be capable of playing as many as 50 games if the youngster's development still lags.

Sign or trade for the best possible goaltender money and cap space can buy. Gustavsson can either back up and wait his turn or be traded for another asset.

At this point, Gustavsson is being given a chance to provide at least part of the answer. Now that Burke and head coach Ron Wilson are fairly sure Gustavsson's health problems, which saw him undergo two heart ablation procedures, are solved, the plan is to give the rookie most of the work between now and the end of the season.

But that is only as long as he continues to play well. So far, he has shown streaks of promise but he has also shown he still has much to learn from goaltending guru François Allaire.

The most likely outcome is that Gustavsson, who does not benefit from playing behind a defensively consistent team, will continue to be up and down. Burke, then, might have to make a call by the March 3 NHL trading deadline if an attractive alternative presents itself.

Story continues below advertisement

That alternative could be Florida Panthers goaltender Tomas Vokoun. Even though the Panthers are almost as inept as the Leafs, Vokoun quietly re-established himself as one of the best goalies in the league.

Word is that if the Panthers remain out of playoff contention leading up to the deadline, GM Randy Sexton will starting looking to trade his goaltender.

Vokoun has one year left on his contract with an attractive salary-cap hit of $5.7-million. If he became available, he would present the Leafs with the kind of goaltending they have not had since the days of Ed Belfour and Curtis Joseph. It was Joseph, don't forget, who was most responsible for turning the Leafs into instant contenders back in 1998.

This type of scenario has been mentioned before, only it involves Burke's goaltender while he was running the Anaheim Ducks, J.S. Giguere. Ducks GM Bob Murray has been hounding his old boss to take Giguere, who would be reunited with his old mentor, Allaire.

The problem here is that Giguere's inconsistency saw him lose the No. 1 job to Jonas Hiller. Plus, he comes with a cap hit of $6-million for next season, which is a little rich given his performance.

Hiller is a more intriguing idea involving the Ducks. He is only 27 years old and becomes an unrestricted free agent. He, too, is an old pupil of Allaire's.

Story continues below advertisement

Other attractions on the unrestricted-free-agent side include Evgeni Nabokov of the San Jose Sharks, who is said to have few friends in that dressing room.

But it is hard to imagine him wanting to play for Wilson again.

There is also Pekka Rinne and Dan Ellis of the Nashville Predators, since the Predators can only afford to keep one of them at best. But that, too, would involve abandoning the Gustavsson experiment, or at least pushing it to the back burner.

That leaves sorting through the free-agent crop for the best veteran to serve as a mentor and, if necessary, a saviour for the team if Gustavsson falters.

The prime candidates here are Martin Biron, 32, of the New York Islanders, Chris Mason, 33, of the St. Louis Blues and Marty Turco, 34, of the Dallas Stars.

Turco is the best choice in that regard. He is a good man in the dressing room. He is also playing well and young enough to handle lots of work next season.

Also, Stars GM Joe Nieuwendyk wants to get younger at that position and does not plan to sign him.

Report an error Licensing Options
About the Author
Hockey columnist

A native of Wainfleet, Ont., David Shoalts joined The Globe in 1984 after working at the Calgary Herald, Calgary Sun and Toronto Sun. He graduated in 1978 from Conestoga College and also attended the University of Waterloo. More

Comments are closed

We have closed comments on this story for legal reasons. For more information on our commenting policies and how our community-based moderation works, please read our Community Guidelines and our Terms and Conditions.