Skip to main content

The Globe and Mail

York president weighs in on religious-rights controversy, calls for discussion

York University president Mamdouh Shoukri is shown at his office in Toronto on Sept 23, 2011.


York University's president has waded into a controversy over the school's decision to approve a male student's request to avoid group work with female peers on religious grounds, looking to assuage public indignation and pivot the debate away from his campus.

In a written statement, president Mamdouh Shoukri stressed that York is committed to upholding Canada's pluralistic values. But he did not address the specifics of the student's request, instead calling for a broader discussion of "the complexities involved" with religious accommodation – an issue "that many people, myself included, feel passionately about."

The student's professor, J. Paul Grayson, sparked a national debate when he refused the request as sexist, even after university administrators overruled him and approved an exception. The university has maintained it was legally obliged do so, even as dean of arts Martin Singer expressed "sincere regret" that he saw no other option because a student enrolled from abroad was accommodated.

Story continues below advertisement

The student who made the request, whose identity is protected by privacy rules, is taking an online sociology course, but Dr. Grayson required his students to meet in groups for an assignment. The student eventually accepted Dr. Grayson's objections and participated in his group.

"Religious accommodation cannot be implemented at the expense of the infringement of the rights of others. We must always safeguard rights such as gender equality, academic freedom and freedom of expression, which form the foundation of any secular post-secondary institution," Dr. Shoukri said.

Brad Duguid, Ontario's Minister of Training, Colleges and Universities, said he respects the university's jurisdiction to make its own decision, but "my inclination would be to side with the views of the prof on this."

"It's my opinion that ... our universities should not be obliged to alter course curriculum in any way that would be seen as discriminatory with regard to gender equality," Mr. Duguid said, calling such equity a "sacrosanct" principle.

Mr. Duguid is the latest of several prominent politicians to disagree with the university, including federal Justice Minister Peter MacKay and Opposition Leader Thomas Mulcair. But Raj Anand, a human rights lawyer and former chief commissioner of the Ontario Human Rights Commission, said the university's stand appears legally defensible, and that religious accommodation laws are designed to protect individuals against majority opinion.

"You don't decide human rights issues by polling," Mr. Anand said.

Dr. Grayson called Dr. Shoukri's statement "a step in the right direction," and perhaps, "a mea culpa." But he continues to insist York made the wrong decision, and is advocating policy change – and perhaps even a royal commission of inquiry – to clarify how competing rights, including those of women, will be safeguarded in public schools.

Story continues below advertisement

Report an error Licensing Options
About the Authors
Banking Reporter

James Bradshaw is banking reporter for the Report on Business. He covered media from 2014 to 2016, and higher education from 2010 to 2014. Prior to that, he worked as a cultural reporter for Globe Arts, and has written for both the Toronto section and the editorial page. More

Washington correspondent

Adrian Morrow covers U.S. politics from Washington, D.C. Previously he was The Globe's Ontario politics reporter. He's covered news, crime and sports for The Globe since 2010. He won the National Newspaper Award for politics reporting in 2016. More


The Globe invites you to share your views. Please stay on topic and be respectful to everyone. For more information on our commenting policies and how our community-based moderation works, please read our Community Guidelines and our Terms and Conditions.

We’ve made some technical updates to our commenting software. If you are experiencing any issues posting comments, simply log out and log back in.

Discussion loading… ✨